Two NES Editions, One Unusual Game
Crater Song is a single-player co-op puzzle game for the original NES, inspired by Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons. You control two characters simultaneously by holding two NES controllers sideways — one in each hand. Premium Edition Games is offering two physical editions: the Silver NES Edition and the Original NES Edition. Both are second-chance preorders estimated for 2026. Here's how they compare.
What Each Edition Includes
- Silver NES Edition: Includes a shiny limited-edition silver NES cartridge with color label, full-color manual, numbered challenge card, and a retro-style box with dust sleeve and Styrofoam block. Extremely limited — fewer than 80 copies remain.
- Original NES Edition: Includes a standard NES cartridge with color label, full-color manual, numbered challenge card, and the same retro-style box with dust sleeve and Styrofoam block. Stock is low — under 280 copies left.
Edition Details at a Glance
- Crater Song - Silver NES Edition: Silver NES Edition: Original NES cartridge with shiny limited-edition silver label. Price $63.97 (catalog comparison $99.95). The silver cartridge is a collectible variant that stands out on a shelf. The higher price reflects its scarcity and special finish.

Crater Song - Silver NES Edition - Crater Song - Original NES Edition: Original NES Edition: Standard NES cartridge with color label. Price $39.57 (catalog comparison $59.95). The original edition offers the same gameplay and manual at a lower price, making it the practical choice for players who care more about playing than collecting.

Crater Song - Original NES Edition
Same Game, Different Cartridge
Both editions contain the same Crater Song game — a sci-fi fantasy adventure where you guide twins through puzzles using singing mechanics. Both play on original NES hardware or emulators. The manual, challenge card, box, dust sleeve, and Styrofoam block are identical. The only difference is the cartridge shell: the Silver Edition has a shiny silver label and is marketed as a limited collectible, while the Original Edition has a standard color label.
Availability and Trade-Offs
The Silver NES Edition is extremely limited — fewer than 80 copies remain — so it's the obvious pick for collectors who want a rare variant. The Original NES Edition is more abundant (under 280 copies) and costs about $24 less. If you plan to play the game and don't need a special cartridge, the Original Edition saves money and still includes everything functional. Both editions are preorders; orders are final and cannot be canceled without approval.
Which Edition Should You Choose?
If you're a retro game collector who values unique variants and limited runs, the Silver NES Edition is the one to grab before it sells out. If you want to experience Crater Song's innovative two-controller gameplay without spending extra on a cosmetic upgrade, the Original NES Edition gives you the full game at a lower price. Either way, you're getting a physical NES release of a genuinely creative indie title.



